Incubation and Creative Blocks: an Essay on Creativity by Guy Tal - Rocky Nook
Share this

Incubation and Creative Blocks: an Essay on Creativity by Guy Tal

The following is an excerpt from Guy Tal’s The Interior Landscape



Anyone involved in creative endeavors likely is familiar with creative blocksโ€”timesย when creative ideas fail persistently to materialize for prolonged periods. When theย creative well runs dry, we often become anxious and seek reassurances, we remindย ourselves of the inevitability of blocks, their transitory nature, perhaps even ofย times when creativity returned with renewed vigor after such episodes. We look forย tips and strategies to break the block, we try to force ourselves to work despite theย malaise, we wish for things to go back to the way they were. Still, as the days turn toย weeks or months, anxiety and doubt keep building. Will this time be an exception?

Thereโ€™s another way to think about creative blocks: not as hindrances to creativityย but as harbingers of creative renewals, as necessary breaks for the mind toย replenish its creative resources, to clean house, to organize and assimilate new ideasย and information.

Psychologist Eric Maisel speculated that to a creative person, creating is a wayย of making meaning. When we are not productive, according to Maisel, we lose ourย sense of meaning and spiral into depression. In his book The Van Gogh Blues, Maiselย wrote, โ€œThis is why creating is such a crucial activity in the life of a creator: It is oneย of the ways, and often the most important way, that she manages to make life feelย meaningful. Not creating is depressing because she is not making meaning whenย she is not creating.โ€ I think Maiselโ€™s point is true regarding creativity, but I also thinkย itโ€™s worthwhile to point out a common misconception, which is this: to be creative isย not the same thing as to be productive.

A creative product may (or may not) be the outcome of โ€œcreating,โ€ but a personย may be creating, in the sense of being engaged in a creative activity, for prolongedย periods before arriving at an idea that may lead to any tangible outcome. As it turnsย out, some of the brain processes involved in giving rise to creative ideas are not conscious.ย The phase of subconscious processing, before an idea or a solution comes toย mind, is known as incubation. When incubating, creators may be โ€œcreatingโ€ withoutย even knowing they are engaged in creative thinking. Even when doing other things.ย Even when asleep. These periods of incubation, therefore, are easy to confuse forย creative blocks.

I am no stranger to creative highs: the experience of flow when immersed inย creative work, the โ€œaha!โ€ moment of revelation or discovery when an exciting ideaย comes to mind, the sense of accomplishment and pride when creating a satisfyingย photograph, an article, or a book. The more original and personally significant theย work, the greater the satisfaction, and the more energized I feel afterward to tackleย my next challenge. Still, the reverse is not true: I donโ€™t feel that my life has lostย meaning when I am not productive.

Some of my most meaningful experiences involve the assimilation of variousย dimensions of my experienceโ€”sensations, contemplations, awe, beautyโ€”leadingย to intense emotions, sometimes to ideas whose usefulness may not be immediatelyย apparent, and that are not ostensibly associated with any product. Such experiencesย may still count as creative if feeding into the subconscious parts of creativeย thinking, which for me are constant by virtue of the fact that I strive constantly toย live a creative life: to shape my attitude toward and engagement with the world byย constantly seeking and aspiring to discoveries, new ideas, and new knowledge. Thereย is no doubt in my mind that these are essential to the conception of future creativeย expressions, even if I may not know what they are or apply any conscious effortย toward them at a given time.

Certainly, those indoctrinated into associating such things as duty and self worthย with work may instinctively associate lack of productivity with such feelingsย as shame and distress. This is unfortunate. Susan Sontag observed this effectย among photographers, writing, โ€œUsing a camera appeases the anxiety which theย workโ€‘driven feel about not working when they are on vacation and supposed to beย having fun. They have something to do that is like a friendly imitation of work: theyย can take pictures.โ€ Bertrand Russell, in an essay titled โ€œIn Praise of Idleness,โ€ wrote,ย โ€œA great deal of harm is being done in the modern world by belief in the virtuousnessย of work.โ€

When it comes to creative work, creativityโ€”incubation and allโ€”must precedeย work. As Timothy Egan put it in a New York Times opinion piece, โ€œCreativity comesย from time off, and time out.โ€ It is good for artists feeling blocked to remind ourselvesย that what we may perceive as a creative block is perhaps better described as a productivityย block. Our creative faculties most likely are intact, perhaps even workingย subconsciously on new ideas, even if at any given time we may fail to come up withย actionable ideas. It is also true, however, that work involving states of flowโ€”even ifย not outright creativeโ€”often begets creative ideas by suppressing distractions andย anxiety. This may suggest that one way to get through creative blocks is to workย through themโ€”clean the studio, do yard work, study, tend to accounting or otherย uncreative demands. In doing so, we may free up cognitive resources for those partsย of our subconscious mind engaged in whatever it is they do while incubating newย ideas. As psychologist Adam Grant put it, โ€œItโ€™s only when youโ€™re told that youโ€™reย going to be working on this problem, and then you start procrastinating, but the taskย is still active in the back of your mind, that you start to incubate. Procrastinationย gives you time to consider divergent ideas, to think in nonlinear ways, to makeย unexpected leaps.โ€

Creative blocks, when they are short-lived, can be unpleasant, and often leadย to a sense of relief when productivity and the flow of ideas return to their normalย levels. Still, I think that there is something unique about notoriously persistentย blocksโ€”those that refuse to yield, for weeks or months. I believe that such blocksย generally accompany significant change in oneโ€™s life, especially for artists committedย to self-expression in their work. When the selfโ€”the personโ€”changes, formerย styles and methods that may have been expressive of the person one was may noย longer express the person one has become. It may be that these prolonged and difficultย blocks, in fact, are indicative of the subconscious mind exploring new waysย to assimilate changes in personality, outlook, lifestyle, or philosophy. Itโ€™s no longerย about finding creative ways to express what one already knows how to express butย about adapting to new knowledge, which by necessity takes longer and may be contingentย on rare moments of insight before resolving itself.

My advice to anyone in the throes of a prolonged creative block is this: Beforeย attempting to stem the block, first cut yourself some slack. Meditate on changes inย your life, open your mind to novel ideas, make yourself comfortable with letting goย of older formulas that may no longer satisfy, and with accepting that your subconsciousย mind may be telling you itโ€™s time to try something new that you may not yetย know how to do. Most important, donโ€™t make an already vexing situation worse byย interpreting what may ultimately be a necessary phase of incubation and creativeย growth as any indication of diminished self-worth, or as reason for self-flagellation.

As psychologists like to say, give yourself permission to use this time to rest andย renew, to explore possibilities, to indulge.ย If the time has come, not just for new work but for new ideas, epiphanies, directions,ย or style, donโ€™t stand in your own way. Give it time. Let the creative circuitry inย your brain do what it needs to do to adapt and to conceive new ways of thinking andย producing work.

Anecdotally, one means of grappling with a creative block that has often workedย for me is to write about creative blocksโ€”to dredge from my mind what I know andย what I have experienced regarding creative blocks. If nothing else, it helps keepย things in perspective and to regain the confidence that, as the adage goes, โ€œthis tooย shall pass.โ€